NeutrogenaMakeup Remover Melting Balm to Oil with Vitamin E, Gentle and Nourishing Makeup Removing Balm for Eye, Lip, or Face Makeup, Travel-Friendly for On-the-Go, 2.0 oz

I was excited to try this as an eye make up remover on the recommendation of a YouTuber. I am underwhelmed. It leaves my eyes feeling heavy and blurry. It looks like set coconut oil. I would rather use coconut oil as it is all-natural. Some ingredients in this tub I can't even pronounce.

This is such a great product. It's a shame not all drugstores carry it. It's very similar in effectiveness as the Elemis balm which is so much more expensive. It doesnt have a scent and works just as well. There's something about the Elemis one that makes it feel more luxe, but at the end of the day this one gets all my make up off just the same. Especially love it for dissolving mascara bc so gentle and effective.

This product worked great for makeup removal. It removes waterproof eyeliner and mascara with ease. I rub lightly on my face and don't have to tug or pull on my skin to remove makeup as it removes it very easily. I wash my face after and it doesn't leave a greasy feeling on my skin. Very happy with this product!!

I love this makeup remover it does the job, doesn’t dry out my skin and has no unpleasant smell like many of the remover wipes

As someone with allergies that give me runny eyes year round, I have always had to use waterproof eyeliners and mascaras to keep my eye make-up on all day. (Hint: Waterproof mascara also helps your eyelashes hold their curl all day too!) The downside is finding a way to gently remove these products without harsh chemicals or rubbing of the delicate eye skin.I've tried all kinds of eye makeup removers, pads and wipes over the years - mostly oil based - but got tired of the multi-step face cleansing every night that usually still left mascara residue and "crumbs" on my face and dark blotches on my washcloth. I've been hearing about these types of solid/melting cleansing balms for awhile, but feared they would be too thick and greasy for my sensitive/clogged pore prone skin.But I've had great luck with other Neutrogena skin products and since this balm is fragrance free and claims to be non-comedogenic, I decided to give it a try. So far, so good. I rub small amount (like the size of a peanut) between my fingers to liquify it then wipe it across my eyelids, lashes, brows, lips and the rest of my face and with only the slightest amount of rubbing/rinsing it does melt away the makeup, including stubborn waterproof mascara and lip stains.I do still take the extra step of a quick rinse with my regular facial cleanser afterwards - but that's just my extra precaution against the clogged pores I've struggled with - probably not necessary for everyone. So far no bad side effects - just a very, very clean feeling on the whole face. Which, now that I think of it, is probably another benefit - a residue-free clean slate to allow your night time skin treatments a better chance to penetrate the skin to do their good work. I plan to keep using this and will purchase again.

This goes on feeling like vasoline but is a good balm for a 2step cleanse. There was no residue after and it got off all my waterproof makeup. I definitely recommend this as a beginner option.